Should I choose herringbone pattern or straight plank design for my floors?

Question

I am hiring professionals to install ceramic tile that is the hardwook plank look. They suggested Herringbone as a consideration. I am not sure if that is for me. I wonder if it would be hard on the eyes. All planks are same color and size, and the grout is dark. It is hard for me to visualize how herringbone would look in my house, though I have searched for pictures online. What are situations in which one would NOT be advised for this pattern? Advantages,disadvantages? I am tiling my entire home. Bedrooms are already tiled with the straight pattern, but what about the large family room, kitchen/dining area, laundry room, etc?

Answer 1

One advantage of the herringbone pattern would be the variation in the design, which would set off the dining area in particular. It would also have a more luxurious look.



However, the herringbone pattern would require a high degree of accuracy in cutting and laying of the material. There would be more of a risk of open cracks if the work were not done perfectly.



Also, as a previous poster said, there would be increased scrap and waste. If it were me, I would prefer the straight pattern throughout, but if you can deal with any problems from the herringbone design, go for it!

Answer 2

Herringbone Flooring Pattern

Answer 3

Personally I like different. There is nothing worse than everyone having the same old thing. I would consider herringbone layout if your rooms are a decent size...they do not have to be huge, but should not be too small. I have seen this done with hardwood flooring and it is fantastic. If you have busy furnishings...cupboards or walls with bead board or bead board effect then I would think that might be too much...too busy for the eyes. I would strongly suggest you look at pictures..maybe visit the flooring stores in your area to check out if they have pics or sample (should have samples) of this layout. Herringbone should not use too much more for the layout. It is not diagonal, just tiles layed on 90 degrees to each other but not cut diagonally. Look long and hard at your surroundings to be sure it will not be too busy. It can add a lot to your home, but it will look nasty if the surroundings are not plain enough to show off the flooring. It sounds lovely. Hat's off to the installers who are suggesting different layouts for you to think about.

Answer 4

I consider the herringbone look a bit old fashion. It is a bit busier look..

One very distinct disadvantage I can see is that you will increase the amount you need since the scrap factor is like that of a diagonal. You will have to buy a bunch more than a straight lay. Now some places charge labor for the amount they handle. Since you will need more to do this pattern labor might be higher too.

Since you say its a ceramic and the same size planks, did they suggest a random hard wood look? This looks nice to me and since you lay the pattern out randomly, there is virtually no scrap.

Any questions you can e mail me through my avatar and check my qualifications there. GL

Answer 5

I think the herringbone pattern will add visual interest and perceived luxury to your space. It will end up costing a little extra, but stepping outside of the box by integrating a timeless pattern such as herringbone into your floor will probably be paid off by your enjoyment and when you go to sell someday. Don't be afraid to combat the generic, neutral boxes to which most people have grown so accustomed. :)

Answer 6

It's truly your personal choice...But here is what I would do.



You are paying ALOT for this floor ..When the installer comes have him lay a section of floor out both ways over your current floor and see what you prefer. Or have a box sent to your home and do a real time mock up yourself.

Answer 7

I didn't make a choice, I was born straight and knew it at about 8 I think. My gay brother was born gay and realized it at about 11 when everyone else wanted to get the attention of the girls and he didn't. Some here are just spouting what they've heard because they're afraid to look at themselves too close. The most rabid homophobic types usually have feelings they want to suppress.